This review is for the 4 pack of charcoal pencils (3 black 1 white) with kneadable eraser. I think it was 2 different soft ones and 1 medium for the black. Anyways, I tracked my order the day after ordering and the listing photo changed to 2 white charcoal pencils and a sharpener. I was very frustrated thinking they shipped the wrong thing, but I received the correct item. The pencils are great. Love this brand. Haven’t tried the eraser yet. Just pay attention and know what you are ordering. I have no idea why this listing appears to have changed.CharcoalThese are a lot easier to use and blend than vine charcoal in my opinion. The white pencil is a great thing to have to highlight.I wasnt very happy with this brand of charcoal pencils. Not only didnt it come with a small sharpener, when I tried to sharpen with my own, all it did was break down. Not very good on a canvas, had to go over it multiple times. Tbis product was a not a winner in my opinion.Use it for art projects, works greatWish they included more then white charcoal penI absolutely love these pencils. I have never really worked with charcoal before, just graphite was my preferred medium. I was really impressed with them. I was originally looking for a white pencil and found a pack of 3 from the same brand, but then came across these. I decided to go with these to try out the charcoal pencils instead since they came with the white pencil too. I found them extremely fun and easy to blend including the white one.It blends just like the charcoal pencils. I found that the best way of sharpening these was to use sand paper. I had a hard time with a regular sharpener that just kept eating the lead and it wouldn't stay in so I just use 220 grit and paper just fine. I also get a nice point that way and also feel like I'm not wasting as much of the pencil by that method of sharpening.Also to my surprise that I didn't realize, it came with a kneading eraser cause to be honest I was looking at the pencils, the price and was super happy with just that. I knew I would end up spending more at the craft store anyway. Would recommend trying these out as a first time charcoal user. I'd even recommend trying as a pro.Edit:It was the pencil sharpener that was causing an issue with sharpening them. I tried a different sharpener and they sharpen beautifully.I also saw these in Michaels when I had made it to the store so it was quite comforting to know it was even sold on a store floor.I've been using the heck out of them now and truly do love these!